Index · 195 metros · rebuilt November 2026

Where renting beats buying, metro by metro

The Rent vs Buy Index ranks every US metro we track by price-to-rent ratio: the typical home value divided by a year of typical rent. Beside it, the mortgage on that typical home at today's 7.28% 30-year rate, the monthly gap against rent, and the rate at which the two would break even.

Renting territory
48
metros over 20x annual rent
Toss-up
101
metros between 15x and 20x
Buying territory
46
metros under 15x
Median metro
17.0x
price-to-rent, all 195 metros
30-yr fixed used
7.28%
Freddie Mac PMMS, November 19, 2026

Jump to: the toss-ups · where buying wins · how this is computed. Click any column heading to sort.

#MetroStPrice-to-rentTypical rentMortgage P&IMonthly gapBreakeven rateVerdict
1San Jose - CACA 33.4x $3,811 $8,372 +$4,561 0.78% Renting territory
2Salt Lake City - UTUT 28.2x $1,637 $3,031 +$1,394 2.00% Renting territory
3Santa Cruz - CACA 28.0x $3,392 $6,239 +$2,847 2.05% Renting territory
4San Francisco - CACA 27.3x $3,438 $6,163 +$2,725 2.24% Renting territory
5Los Angeles - CACA 27.1x $2,913 $5,193 +$2,280 2.28% Renting territory
6San Luis Obispo - CACA 26.7x $2,792 $4,896 +$2,104 2.41% Renting territory
7Seattle - WAWA 26.7x $2,225 $3,897 +$1,672 2.41% Renting territory
8San Diego - CACA 26.3x $2,936 $5,073 +$2,137 2.52% Renting territory
9Salinas - CACA 25.7x $2,740 $4,631 +$1,891 2.69% Renting territory
10Ogden - UTUT 25.6x $1,646 $2,763 +$1,117 2.74% Renting territory
11Green Bay - WIWI 25.0x $1,141 $1,876 +$735 2.90% Renting territory
12Provo - UTUT 25.0x $1,779 $2,916 +$1,137 2.92% Renting territory
13Oxnard - CACA 24.8x $2,920 $4,764 +$1,844 2.96% Renting territory
14Portland - OROR 24.8x $1,799 $2,928 +$1,129 2.98% Renting territory
15Santa Rosa - CACA 24.6x $2,644 $4,273 +$1,629 3.03% Renting territory
16Denver - COCO 24.4x $1,884 $3,019 +$1,135 3.10% Renting territory
17Santa Maria - CACA 24.4x $3,419 $5,474 +$2,055 3.11% Renting territory
18Fargo - NDND 24.2x $1,113 $1,770 +$657 3.16% Renting territory
19Urban Honolulu - HIHI 24.1x $2,976 $4,707 +$1,731 3.20% Renting territory
20Boulder - COCO 24.1x $2,443 $3,862 +$1,419 3.21% Renting territory
21Bremerton - WAWA 23.5x $2,032 $3,138 +$1,106 3.39% Renting territory
22Appleton - WIWI 23.5x $1,230 $1,895 +$665 3.41% Renting territory
23Greeley - COCO 23.2x $1,735 $2,647 +$912 3.49% Renting territory
24Fort Collins - COCO 23.1x $1,952 $2,966 +$1,014 3.52% Renting territory
25Reno - NVNV 23.0x $2,061 $3,117 +$1,056 3.56% Renting territory
26Spokane - WAWA 22.9x $1,488 $2,240 +$752 3.60% Renting territory
27Salem - OROR 22.9x $1,619 $2,431 +$812 3.62% Renting territory
28Sioux Falls - SDSD 22.1x $1,260 $1,833 +$573 3.88% Renting territory
29Yakima - WAWA 21.9x $1,317 $1,892 +$575 3.98% Renting territory
30Kennewick - WAWA 21.7x $1,665 $2,371 +$706 4.05% Renting territory
31Austin - TXTX 21.5x $1,584 $2,239 +$655 4.12% Renting territory
32Raleigh - NCNC 21.4x $1,658 $2,330 +$672 4.16% Renting territory
33Boise City - IDID 21.3x $1,913 $2,682 +$769 4.18% Renting territory
34Phoenix - AZAZ 21.3x $1,717 $2,402 +$685 4.20% Renting territory
35Milwaukee - WIWI 21.2x $1,501 $2,091 +$590 4.23% Renting territory
36Colorado Springs - COCO 21.2x $1,740 $2,420 +$680 4.25% Renting territory
37Olympia - WAWA 21.1x $2,036 $2,822 +$786 4.28% Renting territory
38Wilmington - NCNC 21.1x $1,746 $2,419 +$673 4.28% Renting territory
39Eugene - OROR 20.9x $1,783 $2,452 +$669 4.34% Renting territory
40Sacramento - CACA 20.8x $2,282 $3,125 +$843 4.38% Renting territory
41Nashville - TNTN 20.8x $1,787 $2,444 +$657 4.39% Renting territory
42Boston - MAMA 20.5x $2,945 $3,965 +$1,020 4.52% Renting territory
43Lancaster - PAPA 20.5x $1,563 $2,104 +$541 4.53% Renting territory
44Bridgeport - CTCT 20.4x $2,800 $3,748 +$948 4.57% Renting territory
45Manchester - NHNH 20.4x $2,107 $2,820 +$713 4.58% Renting territory
46Las Vegas - NVNV 20.3x $1,723 $2,295 +$572 4.62% Renting territory
47Providence - RIRI 20.2x $2,145 $2,844 +$699 4.66% Renting territory
48Asheville - NCNC 20.1x $1,712 $2,257 +$545 4.71% Renting territory
49Washington - DCVA 19.9x $2,379 $3,109 +$730 4.78% Toss-up
50Durham - NCNC 19.9x $1,666 $2,176 +$510 4.79% Toss-up
51Madison - WIWI 19.8x $1,850 $2,407 +$557 4.82% Toss-up
52Lincoln - NENE 19.5x $1,271 $1,630 +$359 4.94% Toss-up
53Portland - MEME 19.5x $2,262 $2,901 +$639 4.95% Toss-up
54Fayetteville - ARAR 19.5x $1,549 $1,982 +$433 4.97% Toss-up
55Vallejo - CACA 19.2x $2,460 $3,108 +$648 5.08% Toss-up
56Richmond - VAVA 19.2x $1,694 $2,136 +$442 5.10% Toss-up
57Albuquerque - NMNM 19.2x $1,502 $1,893 +$391 5.10% Toss-up
58Riverside - CACA 19.2x $2,522 $3,173 +$651 5.11% Toss-up
59Des Moines - IAIA 18.9x $1,274 $1,585 +$311 5.21% Toss-up
60York - PAPA 18.9x $1,358 $1,688 +$330 5.22% Toss-up
61Worcester - MAMA 18.9x $2,088 $2,589 +$501 5.24% Toss-up
62Lynchburg - VAVA 18.9x $1,260 $1,561 +$301 5.25% Toss-up
63Salisbury - MDDE 18.8x $1,878 $2,321 +$443 5.27% Toss-up
64Anchorage - AKAK 18.8x $1,869 $2,308 +$439 5.28% Toss-up
65Huntsville - ALAL 18.8x $1,387 $1,712 +$325 5.28% Toss-up
66Modesto - CACA 18.8x $2,051 $2,527 +$476 5.30% Toss-up
67Tucson - AZAZ 18.7x $1,490 $1,831 +$341 5.32% Toss-up
68Crestview - FLFL 18.5x $1,968 $2,395 +$427 5.41% Toss-up
69Minneapolis - MNMN 18.4x $1,733 $2,097 +$364 5.46% Toss-up
70Charlotte - NCNC 18.4x $1,713 $2,072 +$359 5.47% Toss-up
71Albany - NYNY 18.3x $1,681 $2,025 +$344 5.50% Toss-up
72Omaha - NENE 18.3x $1,389 $1,666 +$277 5.54% Toss-up
73Springfield - MOMO 18.1x $1,241 $1,476 +$235 5.62% Toss-up
74Clarksville - TNTN 18.0x $1,329 $1,574 +$245 5.66% Toss-up
75Dallas - TXTX 18.0x $1,647 $1,944 +$297 5.69% Toss-up
76Stockton - CACA 17.9x $2,416 $2,838 +$422 5.73% Toss-up
77Columbus - OHOH 17.8x $1,523 $1,783 +$260 5.76% Toss-up
78Chattanooga - TNTN 17.8x $1,486 $1,738 +$252 5.77% Toss-up
79Evansville - ININ 17.8x $1,050 $1,227 +$177 5.78% Toss-up
80Kansas City - MOMO 17.8x $1,514 $1,769 +$255 5.78% Toss-up
81Roanoke - VAVA 17.7x $1,393 $1,617 +$224 5.84% Toss-up
82Charleston - SCSC 17.6x $2,039 $2,363 +$324 5.86% Toss-up
83New York - NYNY 17.6x $3,450 $3,996 +$546 5.86% Toss-up
84Knoxville - TNTN 17.6x $1,710 $1,979 +$269 5.87% Toss-up
85Jacksonville - FLFL 17.5x $1,661 $1,911 +$250 5.92% Toss-up
86Merced - CACA 17.3x $1,985 $2,260 +$275 6.02% Toss-up
87Harrisburg - PAPA 17.3x $1,473 $1,676 +$203 6.03% Toss-up
88Kalamazoo - MIMI 17.2x $1,321 $1,496 +$175 6.07% Toss-up
89Naples - FLFL 17.2x $2,685 $3,036 +$351 6.09% Toss-up
90Baltimore - MDMD 17.2x $1,916 $2,165 +$249 6.09% Toss-up
91Grand Rapids - MIMI 17.2x $1,705 $1,926 +$221 6.09% Toss-up
92Reading - PAPA 17.2x $1,523 $1,716 +$193 6.12% Toss-up
93Lexington - KYKY 17.1x $1,573 $1,770 +$197 6.13% Toss-up
94Fort Wayne - ININ 17.1x $1,252 $1,403 +$151 6.17% Toss-up
95Norwich - CTCT 17.1x $2,091 $2,343 +$252 6.17% Toss-up
96Fresno - CACA 17.0x $1,977 $2,213 +$236 6.18% Toss-up
97Philadelphia - PAPA 17.0x $1,884 $2,106 +$222 6.19% Toss-up
98Atlanta - GAGA 17.0x $1,828 $2,041 +$213 6.20% Toss-up
99Erie - PAPA 17.0x $1,086 $1,211 +$125 6.21% Toss-up
100Louisville - KYKY 17.0x $1,359 $1,514 +$155 6.22% Toss-up
101Visalia - CACA 16.9x $1,772 $1,971 +$199 6.24% Toss-up
102Hagerstown - MDMD 16.9x $1,581 $1,758 +$177 6.25% Toss-up
103Hartford - CTCT 16.9x $1,957 $2,175 +$218 6.25% Toss-up
104New Haven - CTCT 16.8x $1,997 $2,206 +$209 6.31% Toss-up
105Ann Arbor - MIMI 16.7x $2,032 $2,232 +$200 6.36% Toss-up
106Allentown - PAPA 16.7x $1,809 $1,985 +$176 6.37% Toss-up
107Greenville - SCSC 16.7x $1,550 $1,699 +$149 6.38% Toss-up
108Bakersfield - CACA 16.7x $1,801 $1,971 +$170 6.39% Toss-up
109Orlando - FLFL 16.7x $1,908 $2,088 +$180 6.40% Toss-up
110Cincinnati - OHOH 16.5x $1,540 $1,664 +$124 6.52% Toss-up
111Virginia Beach - VAVA 16.4x $1,878 $2,029 +$151 6.52% Toss-up
112Buffalo - NYNY 16.4x $1,444 $1,555 +$111 6.55% Toss-up
113Myrtle Beach - SCSC 16.4x $1,721 $1,853 +$132 6.55% Toss-up
114Cedar Rapids - IAIA 16.4x $1,237 $1,331 +$94 6.56% Toss-up
115Laredo - TXTX 16.3x $1,098 $1,175 +$77 6.61% Toss-up
116North Port - FLFL 16.2x $2,081 $2,220 +$139 6.64% Toss-up
117San Antonio - TXTX 16.2x $1,402 $1,491 +$89 6.67% Toss-up
118Canton - OHOH 16.2x $1,115 $1,186 +$71 6.67% Toss-up
119Savannah - GAGA 16.1x $1,745 $1,850 +$105 6.70% Toss-up
120Longview - TXTX 16.1x $1,119 $1,182 +$63 6.74% Toss-up
121St. Louis - MOMO 16.0x $1,416 $1,491 +$75 6.77% Toss-up
122Indianapolis - ININ 16.0x $1,510 $1,589 +$79 6.77% Toss-up
123Tallahassee - FLFL 16.0x $1,460 $1,530 +$70 6.82% Toss-up
124Killeen - TXTX 15.9x $1,295 $1,353 +$58 6.85% Toss-up
125Davenport - IAIL 15.8x $1,021 $1,060 +$39 6.91% Toss-up
126South Bend - ININ 15.8x $1,244 $1,291 +$47 6.91% Toss-up
127Spartanburg - SCSC 15.8x $1,448 $1,501 +$53 6.92% Toss-up
128Little Rock - ARAR 15.7x $1,205 $1,245 +$40 6.95% Toss-up
129Atlantic City - NJNJ 15.7x $2,038 $2,104 +$66 6.96% Toss-up
130Deltona - FLFL 15.7x $1,750 $1,806 +$56 6.97% Toss-up
131Cape Coral - FLFL 15.6x $1,795 $1,839 +$44 7.04% Toss-up
132Flint - MIMI 15.6x $1,031 $1,055 +$24 7.05% Toss-up
133College Station - TXTX 15.6x $1,624 $1,662 +$38 7.05% Toss-up
134Fort Smith - ARAR 15.6x $1,066 $1,090 +$24 7.06% Toss-up
135Lansing - MIMI 15.5x $1,307 $1,334 +$27 7.08% Toss-up
136Springfield - MAMA 15.5x $1,988 $2,029 +$41 7.08% Toss-up
137Wichita - KSKS 15.5x $1,180 $1,204 +$24 7.08% Toss-up
138Greensboro - NCNC 15.5x $1,390 $1,417 +$27 7.09% Toss-up
139Houston - TXTX 15.4x $1,622 $1,645 +$23 7.14% Toss-up
140Winston - NCNC 15.4x $1,495 $1,509 +$14 7.19% Toss-up
141Birmingham - ALAL 15.4x $1,407 $1,420 +$13 7.19% Toss-up
142Akron - OHOH 15.3x $1,294 $1,302 +$8 7.22% Toss-up
143Tulsa - OKOK 15.3x $1,363 $1,371 +$8 7.22% Toss-up
144Rochester - NYNY 15.3x $1,523 $1,528 +$5 7.24% Toss-up
145Palm Bay - FLFL 15.1x $1,885 $1,874 -$11 7.34% Toss-up
146Baton Rouge - LALA 15.1x $1,358 $1,344 -$14 7.38% Toss-up
147Miami - FLFL 15.0x $2,652 $2,620 -$32 7.40% Toss-up
148Tampa - FLFL 15.0x $1,975 $1,950 -$25 7.41% Toss-up
149Gainesville - FLFL 15.0x $1,643 $1,622 -$21 7.41% Toss-up
150Kingsport - TNTN 14.9x $1,353 $1,328 -$25 7.47% Buying territory
151Pensacola - FLFL 14.9x $1,711 $1,674 -$37 7.50% Buying territory
152Topeka - KSKS 14.8x $1,219 $1,181 -$38 7.60% Buying territory
153Oklahoma City - OKOK 14.7x $1,370 $1,325 -$45 7.62% Buying territory
154Trenton - NJNJ 14.7x $2,478 $2,394 -$84 7.63% Buying territory
155Fayetteville - NCNC 14.7x $1,437 $1,383 -$54 7.67% Buying territory
156Cleveland - OHOH 14.6x $1,417 $1,363 -$54 7.68% Buying territory
157Detroit - MIMI 14.6x $1,497 $1,432 -$65 7.74% Buying territory
158Waco - TXTX 14.5x $1,438 $1,365 -$73 7.81% Buying territory
159Memphis - TNTN 14.4x $1,400 $1,323 -$77 7.86% Buying territory
160Duluth - MNMN 14.4x $1,501 $1,416 -$85 7.88% Buying territory
161Scranton - PAPA 14.3x $1,353 $1,275 -$78 7.89% Buying territory
162Ocala - FLFL 14.1x $1,581 $1,465 -$116 8.07% Buying territory
163Augusta - GAGA 14.1x $1,469 $1,357 -$112 8.10% Buying territory
164Chicago - ILIL 14.0x $2,123 $1,947 -$176 8.18% Buying territory
165Hickory - NCNC 13.9x $1,590 $1,447 -$143 8.26% Buying territory
166McAllen - TXTX 13.8x $1,133 $1,028 -$105 8.29% Buying territory
167Syracuse - NYNY 13.7x $1,616 $1,459 -$157 8.34% Buying territory
168Lubbock - TXTX 13.7x $1,274 $1,150 -$124 8.35% Buying territory
169Utica - NYNY 13.7x $1,396 $1,256 -$140 8.38% Buying territory
170Port St. Lucie - FLFL 13.7x $2,325 $2,091 -$234 8.39% Buying territory
171Lakeland - FLFL 13.7x $1,791 $1,609 -$182 8.40% Buying territory
172Amarillo - TXTX 13.6x $1,343 $1,198 -$145 8.48% Buying territory
173New Orleans - LALA 13.6x $1,565 $1,393 -$172 8.49% Buying territory
174Youngstown - OHOH 13.5x $1,057 $940 -$117 8.51% Buying territory
175Columbia - SCSC 13.5x $1,560 $1,382 -$178 8.55% Buying territory
176Toledo - OHOH 13.4x $1,248 $1,102 -$146 8.59% Buying territory
177Rockford - ILIL 13.4x $1,378 $1,214 -$164 8.61% Buying territory
178Macon - GAGA 13.4x $1,222 $1,074 -$148 8.64% Buying territory
179Columbus - GAGA 13.1x $1,321 $1,140 -$181 8.84% Buying territory
180El Paso - TXTX 13.1x $1,486 $1,277 -$209 8.88% Buying territory
181Gulfport - MSMS 13.0x $1,420 $1,214 -$206 8.94% Buying territory
182Montgomery - ALAL 12.8x $1,372 $1,157 -$215 9.09% Buying territory
183Pittsburgh - PAPA 12.7x $1,478 $1,235 -$243 9.20% Buying territory
184Huntington - WVOH 12.7x $1,085 $905 -$180 9.22% Buying territory
185Peoria - ILIL 12.6x $1,130 $937 -$193 9.29% Buying territory
186Mobile - ALAL 12.6x $1,271 $1,052 -$219 9.30% Buying territory
187Corpus Christi - TXTX 12.5x $1,451 $1,193 -$258 9.38% Buying territory
188Lafayette - LALA 12.3x $1,361 $1,102 -$259 9.56% Buying territory
189Shreveport - LALA 12.2x $1,236 $994 -$242 9.64% Buying territory
190Jackson - MSMS 12.1x $1,441 $1,144 -$297 9.79% Buying territory
191Beaumont - TXTX 11.9x $1,294 $1,014 -$280 9.94% Buying territory
192Tuscaloosa - ALAL 11.5x $1,722 $1,297 -$425 10.42% Buying territory
193Brownsville - TXTX 11.3x $1,489 $1,107 -$382 10.57% Buying territory
194Charleston - WVWV 10.8x $1,144 $814 -$330 11.12% Buying territory
195Binghamton - NYNY 10.3x $1,634 $1,103 -$531 11.80% Buying territory
Method

How the index is computed

Price-to-rent ratio is the Zillow Home Value Index for the metro divided by twelve months of the Zillow Observed Rent Index. The bands are the long-standing rule of thumb: under 15x, buying tends to pencil out; 15x to 20x is a toss-up that depends on how long you stay and what you could earn on the down payment; over 20x, renting tends to win month to month.

Mortgage P&I is principal and interest on a 30-year fixed loan for 80% of the typical home value (20% down), at 7.28%, the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey average published November 19, 2026, pulled from FRED at build time. It deliberately excludes property tax, insurance, maintenance, HOA dues, and the opportunity cost of the down payment, all of which push the real cost of owning higher. It also excludes the equity you build and any appreciation, which push the other way.

Monthly gap is that mortgage payment minus typical rent. A positive number means the mortgage alone costs more than renting. Breakeven rate is the mortgage rate at which the two would be equal; "none" means the mortgage costs more than rent even at 0%, and "any rate" means buying is cheaper even at 25%.

Data: Zillow Research ZHVI and ZORI (monthly), Freddie Mac PMMS via FRED (weekly). Rebuilt November 2026. This is market-level context, not financial advice. Methodology →

Get new posts in your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.